Firewatch's Original Ending: Would a Different Conclusion Have Changed Everything?

Sean Vanaman, the co-founder of Campo Santo and creative director of Firewatch, has always been known for his bold storytelling approach. However, what would have happened if he had gone ahead with his original ending? The game's unique setting and story are just one of its many strengths, but a different conclusion could have altered the entire experience.

The original plan was to have Delilah disappear after experiencing her chemistry with Henry. This would have left Henry feeling isolated and paranoid, without anyone to confide in or share his experiences with. The game's narrative would have taken a darker turn, with Henry's already fragile mental state deteriorating further.

It's interesting to consider how different Firewatch would have been if Delilah had vanished after their heart-to-heart conversation. The final part of the game would likely have been less engaging, and her disappearance would have been out of character for Delilah. Her absence would have left a significant void in the story, affecting the player's emotional investment in Henry's journey.

Moreover, considering how integral Henry and Delilah's relationship is to the game's positive reception, it's easy to imagine Firewatch receiving a much more negative reaction if Delilah had been missing for nearly a third of the game. The first pass they recorded showed Delilah telling Henry he was crazy and asking him to leave her alone before going cold on him. This would have left players feeling disconnected from the story and characters.

Ultimately, it's impossible to know for sure how different Firewatch would be if Vanaman had stuck with his original ending. However, it's clear that Delilah's presence is a crucial element in making the game as impactful as it is. The game's ability to evoke emotions and tell a compelling story is largely due to the strong bond between Henry and Delilah.

Firewatch may have taken an interesting turn if Vanaman had pursued his original ending, but it's likely that the game would not be the same critically acclaimed experience we know today. As it stands, Firewatch remains a masterclass in storytelling, with its unique setting and characters making it a standout title in the gaming world.

Different endings in firewatch